The Top 5 Most Popular Car Insurance Companies in Surprise, AZ

Compare Quotes from Top Providers and Save now!

The average cost of auto insurance in Surprise, AZ, is $932. This is much lower than the cost of car insurance in neighboring places such as Citrus Park, Youngtown, and El Mirage. Car owners can compare multiple auto insurance quotes to save more on insurance. Using market share data gathered for Arizona, Zimlon has found the following insurers to be among the top 5 insurance companies in Surprise.



            GEICO, a subsidiary of Berkshire Hathaway, leads the way with a market share of 15.86% in Arizona. The company has 509,982 direct premiums written, and 491,351 direct premiums earned. A renowned firm for insurance, car owners continue to repose their faith in GEICO. It enjoys an A++ A.M. Best rating, which is the highest rating a company can receive. The J.D. Power 2019 Auto Insurance Study gave GEICO a commendable score of 818/1000 in the Southwest Region. 


            State Farm is a close second, with a market share of 14.85% in Arizona. The company also occupies the largest market share in the country. State Farm has 477,344 direct premiums written, and  478,758 direct premiums earned. State Farm’s favorability has gone up in recent times, thanks to its robust marketing and advertising strategies. With a J.D. Power Circle score of 831/1000, State Farm occupies the upper-half of these rankings. J.D. Power gives it the “among the best” tag in the Southwest Region. To add to this, it also received an A.M. Best rating of A++.


           Progressive is third on the list, with a market share of 12.64%. Progressive has 406,283 direct premiums written, and 385,313 direct premiums earned. It occupies the lower half of the J.D. Power Ratings, with a score of 807/1000. Progressive is one of the first companies to offer insurance quotes on mobile devices. It also offers Pet Insurance coverage. Progressive has an A+ A.M. Best Rating.


                Farmers enjoys a market share of 7.92% in Arizona. It has 254,781 direct premiums written, and 250,612 direct premiums earned. Farmers has a J.D. Power score of 812/1000, which is about average. In 2005, 2006, and 2007, Farmers Insurance Group won the J.D. Power award for Call Center Customer Service Excellence. It has an A.M. Best Rating of A. 


                United Services Automobile Association (USAA) rounds up the top 5 insurers in Arizona, with a market share of 7.48%. USAA has 240,335 direct premiums written, and 233,132 direct premiums earned. USAA has a top-notch J.D. Power score of 887/1000, which gives it the “among the best” tag. USAA has an A.M. Best Rating of A++.