The average cost of car insurance in  Shirley,  NY, is $1430. Depending upon various factors like the neighborhood, age of the driver, and make and model of the car, insurance costs can get as high as $7690 or as low as $900 in Shirley, NY. According to Zimlon’s research, Shirley, NY residents can save $570 by comparing multiple quotes and reading reviews on Shirley,  NY, car insurance rates, quotes, agents, and coverage. Below is a list by Zimlon of the top five car insurance companies in Shirley, NY, by market share.

GEICO: 

Geico is in the first position with a massive direct premium written of 4,555,220 and  4,481,545 direct premiums earned. According to NAIC data, Geico’s market share in New York is 32.58%. In Shirley, NY, Geico’s car insurance costs can vary depending on factors like vehicle equipment, driving history and habits, driver's education, driver affiliations, and customer loyalty.

ALLSTATE:

Allstate is in the second position with 1,897,997 direct premiums written and 1,883,643 direct premiums earned. The market share of Allstate in New York is 13.57%, as per NAIC data. For car owners in Shirley, NY, factors such as the driver’s age, annual mileage, coverage type, and driver’s credit scores can influence car insurance costs.

STATE FARM: 

State Farm is in the third position with 1,756,075 direct premiums written and 1,762,321 direct premiums earned. The market share of State Farm in the state of New York is 12.56% as per the NAIC record. For car owners in Shirley, NY, State Farm offers numerous discounts to lower the cost of car insurance. These discounts include accident-free discounts, anti-theft discounts, and driver improvement course discounts.

PROGRESSIVE: 

The progressive insurance group is in the fourth position with 1,477,674 direct premiums written and 1,432,780 direct premiums earned. The progressive insurance group recorded a market share of 10.57% in New York, according to the NAIC data. Besides the usual auto insurance choices, the Progressive insurance group offers other typical add-on options like roadside assistance and rental car coverage for car owners in Shirley, NY. 

LIBERTY: 

Liberty is in the fifth position with 761,979 direct premiums written and 739,195 direct premiums earned. The market share of Liberty in New York is 5.45%, according to the NAIC data. For car owners in Shirley, NY, factors such as the driver’s age, annual mileage, coverage type, and driver’s credit scores can influence the cost of car insurance offered by Liberty insurance group.