Top 5 Car Insurance Companies in Staten Island, NY, by Market Share

Compare Quotes from Top Providers and Save now!

The average cost of auto insurance in Staten Island, NY, is $1,857. This is much higher than the cost of auto insurance in neighboring places such as Linden, Sewaren, Avenel, and Carteret. The cost of auto insurance is influenced by numerous factors ranging from the make and model of the car to the age of the driver. Below is a list of the top 5 auto insurance companies in Staten Island, NY.

top_5_car_insurance_companies_in_staten_island_ny

GEICO:

GEICO leads the way in New York with a market share of 32.58%. It has 4,555,220 direct premiums written, and 4,481,545 direct premiums earned. J.D. Power has given GEICO a score of 823/1000, which is considered to be “above average.”

Allstate:

Founded in 1931, Allstate is one of the leading insurance providers in the country. It is second on this list with 1,897,997 direct premiums written and 1,883,643 direct premiums earned, giving it a market share of 13.57% in New York. J.D. Power rates Allstate as an “above average” insurance provider with a score of 831/1000.

State Farm:

State Farm is a close third with a market share of 12.56%. It has 1,756,075 direct premiums written and 1,762,321 direct premiums earned. J.D. Power gave it a score of 845/1000, which is considered to be “better than most.”

Progressive:

Progressive was established in 1937. It has a market share of 10.57% and is fourth on the list behind State Farm. It has 1,477,674 direct premiums written and 1,432,780 direct premiums earned. J.D. Power gave Progressive a score of 815/1000.

Liberty Mutual:

Liberty Mutual completes the list of the top 5 auto insurance companies in New York, with a market share of 5.45%. Liberty Mutual has 761,979 direct premiums written, and 739,195 direct premiums earned. J.D. Power has given it a score of 819/1000, which is not very high when compared to the other insurance providers on this list.