Find cheap Middlebury, IN Home Insurance Quotes

Find cheap Middlebury, IN quotes using our fast service. After you get multiple quotes, compare them to what other homeowners are paying.

Compare Cheap Quotes from Top Companies

These estimates are based on Surveys from Middlebury, IN Homeowners. To get the most accurate & cheapest rate, compare quotes from the best Middlebury, IN home insurance companies.

Liberty Mutual



$84/month for a deductible of $500 and coverage of $200000 for a 1620 sqft 4 bed, 1 bath home built in 1992.

Nearby Liberty Mutual Agent:
John Carr,
1018 E Dupont Rd,
Fort Wayne, IN, 46825-1554
Phone : 260-489-3838

Allstate



$101/month for a deductible of $500 and coverage of $200000 for a 2250 sqft 3 bed, 2 baths home built in 1993.

Nearby Allstate Agent:
Bonni Menting,
60900 Us 31 S,
South Bend, IN, 46614-5148
Phone : 574-291-8000

Erie Insurance



$70/month for a deductible of $500 and coverage of $150000 for a 1770 sqft 3 bed, 1 bath home built in 1994.

Nearby Erie Insurance Agent:
Hughes Insurance Group,
123 W Garro Street,
Plymouth, IN, 46563

Farmers Insurance



$52/month for a deductible of $500 and coverage of $150000 for a 1510 sqft 5 bed, 1 bath home built in 1947.

Nearby Farmers Insurance Agent:
Richard Drzewiecki,
3014 Ardmore Trl,
South Bend, IN, 46628
Phone : (574) 289-5300

State Farm



$54/month for a deductible of $11000 and coverage of $200000 for a 2150 sqft 4 bed, 3 baths home built in 1980.

Nearby State Farm Agent:
Stan Ellis,
905 E Cork St,
Kalamazoo, MI, 49001-4875
Phone : 269-384-0500

Farmers Insurance



$99/month for a deductible of $11000 and coverage of $350000 for a 2910 sqft 4 bed, 2 baths home built in 1943.

Nearby Farmers Insurance Agent:
Parker Insurance Agency,
10729 Coldwater Road Suite 100,
Fort Wayne, IN, 46845

Erie Insurance



$59/month for a deductible of $11000 and coverage of $200000 for a 2090 sqft 3 bed, 2 baths home built in 2013.

Nearby Erie Insurance Agent:
The Nulty Agency Inc,
5579 Stadium Dr,
Kalamazoo, MI, 49009

Liberty Mutual



$62/month for a deductible of $4500 and coverage of $175000 for a 1800 sqft 3 bed, 2 baths home built in 2004.

Nearby Liberty Mutual Agent:
Lisa Yoder,
23809 Us Highway 33,
Elkhart, IN, 46517-3509
Phone : 574-875-2525

Erie Insurance



$124/month for a deductible of $500 and coverage of $250000 for a 2530 sqft 5 bed, 3 baths home built in 2011.

Nearby Erie Insurance Agent:
HOSTETLER INSURANCE AGENCY INC,
124 N Detroit Street,
Lagrange, IN, 46761

Allstate



$63/month for a deductible of $2000 and coverage of $175000 for a 2150 sqft 4 bed, 3 baths home built in 1946.

Nearby Allstate Agent:
Justin Harkelroad,
220 Insurance Dr Ste D,
Fort Wayne, IN, 46825
Phone : (260) 216-0057

American Family Insurance



$103/month for a deductible of $500 and coverage of $250000 for a 2310 sqft 4 bed, 3 baths home built in 1982.

State Farm



$71/month for a deductible of $500 and coverage of $175000 for a 2530 sqft 5 bed, 1 bath home built in 1944.

Nearby State Farm Agent:
Greg Sutter,
1415 Lincolnway W Ste B,
Osceola, IN, 46561-2060
Phone : 574-674-5858

State Farm



$28/month for a deductible of $4500 and coverage of $120000 for a 1840 sqft 5 bed, 2 baths home built in 2011.

Nearby State Farm Agent:
KFG Insurance Agency,
6910 N Main St 6910 N Main St Granger,
Mishawaka, IN, 46530