Santa Maria, CA Auto Insurance Rates

Santa Maria, CA residents can save $410 by comparing multiple quotes & reading reviews & research on Santa Maria car insurance rates, quotes, agents & coverage.

Compare Quotes from Top Providers and Save now!

$783 $1014 $1324

Latest Auto Insurance Reviews in Santa Maria, California

They offer pretty much thee same as other policies, they do have AARP discounts and if you take an online test you can get a discount. However you have to repeat every three years.
State Farm
State Farm gets my recommendation for outstanding service, ideal coverage options, agreeable payment terms, and for efficient handling of all claims payable under your policy.
AllState's car insurance policy offerings are pretty good, in the sense that they offer as much offers as other high tier insurance providers - but there are one or two companies that beat it.
It has been good. The one accident I was in was the other lady's fault and they told me not to worry about it. The other insurance company already contacted them and they took it from there.
The price was extremely favorable compared to previous coverage and my experiences with customer service have been good.
Encompass Insurance
I just recently switched the Encompass for my auto insurance. They have been very helpful, but I haven't had to make a claim, etc.
Safeway insurance has it's ups and downs for sure. I had gotten into an accident and only had a small dent in the car, but I called my agent and she never got back with me. When I called again, she was away from her desk and never returned my call. I am very disappointed in this company.
Safeway insurance has it's ups and downs for sure. I had gotten into an accident and only had a small dent in the car, but I called my agent and she never got back with me. When I called again, she was away from her desk and never returned my call. I am very disappointed in this company.
I think that their charges could be better and that they should offer discounts to loyal customers instead of solely focusing on new customer discounts. I would like to see more extras added to their policy over all.
I love allstate rewards and my allstate bonus check at the end of my policy for my great driving. The allstate app is so easily accessible and easy to use. I love the fact that I am assigned my own agent who is there to help me out with any problems i may have.
I think that different people will find the lowest premium with different insurance companies. In my case Geico beats the lowest quote I could find by over $40. They offer more and varied discounts than I have found elsewhere and Geico even offers discounts on getting qualified for discounts, an example of this is that they offer a discount on a defensive driving course which would lower your premium up to 5%.
The Hartford
My company provided a competitive rate for my premium. It was cheaper than most other companies
I like the fact that there is usually a live agent to talk to online at most times. My windshield got cracked, and there was someone available to file a claim even when it wasn't typical business hours.
I really don't have any dislikes. Everything I've ever requested/needed from them has been handled quickly and efficiently.
I think it is a good company that after being with them many year no other company can offer a better price
Write Your Review | Santa Maria, California Auto Insurance Analysis
State Farm Auto Insurance, Santa Maria, CA
$74/1 month
Car Insurance Policy Holder
  • Divorced 39 Years old Female licensed 21 years ago with Financed Kia Optima LX used for Business with estimated annual mileage of 12,001 - 15,000.
  • PhD & Full Time Job.
  • No accidents , No traffic tickets , No DUIs , No Licence suspensions .
Car Insurance Policy & Coverage Details:
  • 1 car insured & 1 person is part of this policy
  • Home and Auto insurance are from difference companies
  • $25K (Per Person Bodily Injury) / $50K (Per Accident Bodily Injury)
  • 20 K Property Damage
  • 50 K Personal Injury Protection
  • 25 K Uninsured Motorists Bodily Injury
  • 50 K Uninsured Motorists Property Damage

Santa Maria Car Insurance Rate Comparisons

Santa Maria, CA's average car insurance of $1014 differs from Nipomo, CA (+$756), Orcutt, CA (+$986), Sisquoc, CA (+$1506) and California (+$805)

Santa Maria Nipomo, CA Orcutt, CA Sisquoc, CA California
Median Insurance Rates $1014 +$756 +$986 +$1506 +$805

Santa Maria Car Insurance Savings By Neighborhood & Street Area

Santa Maria Driver Street Residence & Car Locations Car Details in Santa Maria Santa Maria Driver Demographics Santa Maria Auto Insurance Estimates Recent Santa Maria Insurance Savings
Via Rosa2003 Buick Rendezvous CX19 year female teenager$2211$623
S Curryer St2004 Cadillac Seville SLS16 year teenager$2454$956
La Maria Mobile Home Park
Haslam Dr2008 Ford Fusion SEL81 year female senior$1000$426
S McClelland St2003 Chevrolet Silverado 2500HD LS29 year married woman$893$963
Roadamite (historical)
Esplanada Ave2010 Mazda Mazda3 s Sport29 year married man$1170$376
del Norte Way2010 Nissan Rogue S Krom19 year male teenager$2108$562
North Santa Maria
N Lucas Dr2013 Honda Civic LX74 year senior$934$792
Orchard St2012 Hyundai Sonata GLS48 year woman$968$456
Cimarron Estates
Esplanada Ave2009 Acura TSX Base61 year male senior$1034$559
del Norte Way2008 Chrysler 300 C35 year man$1275$931

Santa Maria Post DUI Car Insurance Rates

Santa Maria Casmalia Blacklake Los Berros California
Median Post DUI Insurance Rate $1886 +$2540 +$2819 +$2503 +$1497
Male Teenager Post DUI Insurance Rate $4110 +$5539 +$6147 +$5457 +$3264
Female Teenager Post DUI Insurance Rate $4092 +$5513 +$6119 +$5433 +$3249

The Post DUI insurance in Santa Maria, CA's is $1886 compared to Casmalia (+$2540), Blacklake (+$2819), Los Berros (+$2503) and California (+$1497)

In Santa Maria, a male teenager with Post DUI pays $18 more than a female teenager Post DUI. For Example, a Male Teenager Post DUI with a 2008 Ford Fusion SEL in Santa Maria, CA would pay $3753 on auto insurance while a female teenager POST DUI would pay $3736.

Santa Maria Car Insurance by Segment

Santa Maria Teenagers Car Insurance Rates Comparison

10714 Santa Maria Teenagers (8% of total population), 53% Male & 47% Female.

Santa Maria Guadalupe Garey Callender California
All Teenagers $2210 +$15 +$885 +$3065 +$1755
Male Teenager $2210 +$15 +$885 +$3065 +$1755
Female Teenager $2200 +$15 +$881 +$3051 +$1747

Santa Maria teenagers pay $2210 in insurance in contrast with Guadalupe (+$15), Garey (+$885), Callender (+$3065) and California (+$1755). The difference between Male & Female teenagers in Santa Maria is $10


  • 2011 Kia Sorento LX Male Teenager Insurance Rate $1938
  • 2012 Dodge Journey Crew Female Teenager Insurance Rate $2317

Santa Maria Men & Women Car Insurance

132286 Santa Maria Adults (100% of total population), 50% Men & 50% Women.

Santa Maria Mission Hills Solvang-Santa Ynez Casmalia California
All Women $983 +$1024 +$1451 +$1325 +$781
Married Women $953 +$992 +$1406 +$1284 +$756
All Men $1287 +$1341 +$1900 +$1735 +$1023
Married Men $1226 +$1278 +$1811 +$1653 +$974

The typical insurance rate of $1287 that Santa Maria Men pay varies from Mission Hills (+$1341), Solvang-Santa Ynez (+$1900), Casmalia (+$1735) and California (+$1023). In Santa Maria, married men pay $273 more than married women.


  • 2011 Lincoln MKZ Base Married Men Insurance Rate $1406
  • 2013 Volkswagen Beetle TDI Married Women Insurance Rate $1173

Santa Maria Senior Car Insurance

20189 Santa Maria Seniors (15% of total population), 44% Senior Men & 56% Senior Women.

Santa Maria Guadalupe Sisquoc Orcutt California
All Seniors $1074 +$8 +$1597 +$1046 +$854
Senior Men $1054 +$7 +$1566 +$1026 +$837
Senior Women $1095 +$7 +$1626 +$1065 +$869

Santa Maria seniors pay $1074 in insurance compared to Guadalupe (+$8), Sisquoc (+$1597), Orcutt (+$1046) and California (+$854). In Santa Maria, senior men pay $41 less than senior women.

Santa Maria Car Insurance Discounts for Multiple Vehicles

Santa Maria Population with 1 Vehicle 11389 (29% of Santa Maria population), 2 Vehicles 14955 (38% of the Santa Maria population) and 3 vehicles 6684 (17% of the population)

Santa Maria Orcutt Casmalia Callender California
2 Vehicles $1927 +$1873 +$2595 +$2671 +$1530
3 Vehicles $2941 +$2859 +$3961 +$4077 +$2335
4 Vehicles $3955 +$3845 +$5327 +$5483 +$3140

Santa Maria Auto Insurance Rates Vary by Deductible

Low Deductible ($500) High Deductible ($1000)
Make & Model Example Claim Amount Yearly Premium Total Yearly Cost Yearly Premium Total Yearly Cost Net Savings for High Deductible Plan
Ford, Flex SEL $500 $1020 $1520 $950 $1450 $70
Porsche, Cayenne $200 $980 $1180 $910 $1110 $70
Chevrolet, Avalanche LT $300 $1010 $1310 $930 $1230 $80
Hyundai, Genesis 2.0T Premium $1500 $980 $1480 $910 $2410 $-930
Hyundai, Elantra GLS $400 $970 $1370 $910 $1310 $60