St. Augustine, FL Auto Insurance Rates

St. Augustine, FL residents can save $450 by comparing multiple quotes & reading reviews & research on St. Augustine car insurance rates, quotes, agents & coverage.

Compare Quotes from Top Providers and Save now!

$835 $1116 $1570

Latest Auto Insurance Reviews in St. Augustine, Florida

Progressive offered the best price for my wife and I's cars. They also have this safe driver thing that you use and it gives you certain discounts which is always nice.
I am very satisfied with my insurance company. Customer service is always prompt and they also offer automated responses to save time instead of waiting on hold.
My insurance company is very comparable to others I shopped in choosing a company - they offer the same basic coverages and policies, and offer insurance on other types of vehicles.
Sometimes it is hard to contact my insurance company for things besides my car, such as the business hours for pet insurance.
My auto insurance company is USAA. In my opinion, they have the cheapest car insurance rates and it is cheaper to obtain roadside assistance compared to other companies like Geico, for instance.
The customer service/accessibility is very poor. They have an online chat function, that only appears to work when you have a question about getting new insurance. The chat can not or does not answer questions about existing policies. I have called the company directly with questions about the snap shot program and spoke to agents that did not have a good understanding of the program, and therefore could not answer questions. There are not local agents for progressive in my area, or there are not according to their customer service department.
USAA is my auto insurance company. They are fantastic. From tow trucks after an accident to window replacement, they offer great insurance for affordable prices. I rate them very highly in relation to the their competition . I would rate them as a 1.
it can be hard to find all of the information i am looking for if i have a specific questions. sometimes i have to call them because the answer is not available online
Auto-Owners Insurance
When I did the comparison when shopping for Home insurance NJM was not the cheapest company but I get to have a single point of contact when filing a claim.
Safeco Insurance
I like how they help you find the best pricing for what you are getting. Everyone I have talked to seems very knowledgeable compared to other companies also.
There are not many things that I dislike about GEICO, but I feel that they could improve even more on their pricing. Although I have shopped around and they are the lowest, I feel that the pricing could be even lower and they should strive to make it decrease for their consumers in order to become even more competitive.
I have called numerous car insurance companies and the premium was extremely high compared to Geico. Sometimes it was almost double what I am paying now.
They have an app as well as a very friendly and efficient call center staff. The last time I used a claim I had a tow truck in 10 minutes and I wasn't in an especially well-populated area.
Write Your Review | St. Augustine, Florida Auto Insurance Analysis
Nationwide Insurance, St. Augustine, FL
$87/1 month
Car Insurance Policy Holder
  • Divorced 76 Years old Female licensed 11 years ago with Own Honda Insight EX used for Business with estimated annual mileage of 12,001 - 15,000.
  • less than high school education & Retired.
  • No accidents , No traffic tickets , No DUIs , No Licence suspensions .
Car Insurance Policy & Coverage Details:
  • 1 car insured & 1 person is part of this policy
  • Home and Auto insurance are from difference companies
  • $25K (Per Person Bodily Injury) / $50K (Per Accident Bodily Injury)
  • 50 K Property Damage
  • 50 K Personal Injury Protection
  • 25 K Uninsured Motorists Bodily Injury
  • 50 K Uninsured Motorists Property Damage

St. Augustine Car Insurance Rate Comparisons

St. Augustine, FL's average car insurance of $1116 differs from Butler Beach, FL (+$744), St. Augustine Beach, FL (+$744), St. Augustine South (+$294) and Florida (+$248)

St. Augustine Butler Beach, FL St. Augustine Beach, FL St. Augustine South Florida
Median Insurance Rates $1116 +$744 +$744 +$294 +$248

St. Augustine Car Insurance Savings By Neighborhood & Street Area

St. Augustine Driver Street Residence & Car Locations Car Details in St. Augustine St. Augustine Driver Demographics St. Augustine Auto Insurance Estimates Recent St. Augustine Insurance Savings
South Ponte Vedra Beach
Old Dixie Dr2005 Buick Rendezvous CX19 year teenager$2497$584
Palmetto Dr2010 Toyota Prius I74 year male senior$1635$357
Saint Augustine South
Fiddlers Ct2012 Honda Civic LX66 year female senior$1523$675
Oleander St2007 Ford Fusion SEL18 year male teenager$2859$634
River Pointe Ct2008 Acura TSX Base78 year senior$1672$580
Co Rd 2082010 Mazda Mazda3 s Sport30 year married man$1689$378
Beachwood Trailer Park
Madison St2011 Hyundai Sonata GLS51 year man$1805$692
Amelia Ct2011 Kia Sorento LX42 year married woman$904$411
Davis Shores
State Hwy 5a2012 Dodge Journey SXT30 year woman$998$868
Lighthouse Ave2008 Chrysler 300 SRT-818 year female teenager$2433$700

St. Augustine Post DUI Car Insurance Rates

St. Augustine Fleming Island Neptune Beach Crescent Beach Florida
Median Post DUI Insurance Rate $2075 +$1347 +$343 +$1273 +$462
Male Teenager Post DUI Insurance Rate $5583 +$3622 +$921 +$3423 +$1241
Female Teenager Post DUI Insurance Rate $4981 +$3232 +$822 +$3054 +$1106

The Post DUI insurance in St. Augustine, FL's is $2075 compared to Fleming Island (+$1347), Neptune Beach (+$343), Crescent Beach (+$1273) and Florida (+$462)

In St. Augustine, a male teenager with Post DUI pays $602 more than a female teenager Post DUI. For Example, a Male Teenager Post DUI with a 2012 Honda Civic LX in St. Augustine, FL would pay $5293 on auto insurance while a female teenager POST DUI would pay $4722.

St. Augustine Car Insurance by Segment

St. Augustine Teenagers Car Insurance Rates Comparison

6264 St. Augustine Teenagers (6% of total population), 52% Male & 48% Female.

St. Augustine Hastings Nocatee St. Augustine Beach Florida
All Teenagers $2812 +$1270 +$1925 +$1875 +$625
Male Teenager $3002 +$1355 +$2055 +$2001 +$667
Female Teenager $2678 +$1210 +$1834 +$1786 +$595

St. Augustine teenagers pay $2812 in insurance in contrast with Hastings (+$1270), Nocatee (+$1925), St. Augustine Beach (+$1875) and Florida (+$625). The difference between Male & Female teenagers in St. Augustine is $324


  • 2012 Lincoln MKZ Base Male Teenager Insurance Rate $3050
  • 2013 Nissan Rogue S Female Teenager Insurance Rate $2654

St. Augustine Men & Women Car Insurance

100901 St. Augustine Adults (100% of total population), 48% Men & 52% Women.

St. Augustine Matanzas Fruit Cove Jacksonville East Florida
All Women $1026 +$13 +$657 +$133 +$228
Married Women $937 +$12 +$600 +$121 +$208
All Men $1841 +$23 +$1178 +$238 +$409
Married Men $1785 +$23 +$1143 +$231 +$397

The typical insurance rate of $1841 that St. Augustine Men pay varies from Matanzas (+$23), Fruit Cove (+$1178), Jacksonville East (+$238) and Florida (+$409). In St. Augustine, married men pay $848 more than married women.


  • 2013 Volkswagen Jetta GLI PZEV Married Men Insurance Rate $1844
  • 2012 GMC Sierra 1500 SLE Married Women Insurance Rate $1752

St. Augustine Senior Car Insurance

22074 St. Augustine Seniors (21% of total population), 45% Senior Men & 55% Senior Women.

St. Augustine Matanzas Fleming Island Palm Valley Florida
All Seniors $1651 +$21 +$1072 +$1101 +$367
Senior Men $1696 +$21 +$1100 +$1131 +$377
Senior Women $1607 +$20 +$1042 +$1071 +$357

St. Augustine seniors pay $1651 in insurance compared to Matanzas (+$21), Fleming Island (+$1072), Palm Valley (+$1101) and Florida (+$367). In St. Augustine, senior men pay $89 more than senior women.

St. Augustine Car Insurance Discounts for Multiple Vehicles

St. Augustine Population with 1 Vehicle 13524 (34% of St. Augustine population), 2 Vehicles 18809 (48% of the St. Augustine population) and 3 vehicles 4009 (10% of the population)

St. Augustine Jacksonville Beach Jacksonville East Palm Valley Florida
2 Vehicles $2121 +$1356 +$273 +$1413 +$471
3 Vehicles $3237 +$2070 +$417 +$2157 +$719
4 Vehicles $4353 +$2784 +$561 +$2901 +$967

St. Augustine Auto Insurance Rates Vary by Deductible

Low Deductible ($500) High Deductible ($1000)
Make & Model Example Claim Amount Yearly Premium Total Yearly Cost Yearly Premium Total Yearly Cost Net Savings for High Deductible Plan
Chevrolet, Silverado 1500 LT $100 $1130 $1230 $1080 $1180 $50
Chrysler, Town & Country Limited $400 $1100 $1500 $1020 $1420 $80
Mitsubishi, Outlander ES $200 $1110 $1310 $1030 $1230 $80
Ford, Transit Connect XLT Premium $300 $1160 $1460 $1110 $1410 $50
Suzuki, Kizashi SLS $500 $1240 $1740 $1170 $1670 $70